How is it possible?
On 23 May 2021 the unthinkable happened: a cable from the Alpino-Mottarone cable car in picturesque Stresa near Lago Majore snapped.
The cabin carrying fifteen people crashed just before it reached the top of the mountainside, in the middle of the forest. Fourteen people were killed. At the time of writing this opinion piece, the owner, the operations manager and the technical engineer of the cabin operating company have been arrested, after it was discovered that the emergency brakes had been deliberately put out of action.
Maintenance was carried out correctly
The cable car, built in 1967, has been thoroughly renovated in recent years. From 2014 to 2016, for example, Leitner systematically replaced the load-bearing and traction cables until an incident occurred. The mechanical safety components were checked at the end of March and the hydraulic brakes of the cabins were also checked and serviced at the beginning of May.
No doubt you are familiar with the phenomenon: technical problems more often occur after a standstill. The cable car opened its doors again only a month earlier after a long period of downtime due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Apparently, there had been problems with the braking system for some time, which caused serious delays. In order to solve the problems, a lengthy intervention was required. This would have meant delays and a shut down that the company could do without just when tourists were starting to arrive again. The solution was simple: to 'bridge' the emergency brake by inserting clamps. According to the public prosecutor, this 'quick fix' had been used regularly in recent years. For a month, the cabin with the clamp in the emergency brake system climbed and descended, until that fatal Sunday...
The fateful decision to put the emergency brakes out of action was partly prompted by a blind faith in the integrity of the cables. All traction and carrier cables were checked in November 2020 via magneto-inductive control. And although the cabin was running at only half capacity due to the Corona measures, the cable still snapped. The future will tell whether or not something went wrong with the safety inspection. For now, we can only conclude that this failure also occurred after a longer period of downtime. To put it in the words of the actress and philanthropist Helen Hayes: “If you rest, you rust.”
Unfortunately, this disaster is not the first accident with cable cars caused by deliberately deactivating the emergency braking system. In 1990, twenty people died in a similar accident in Tbilisi. "The cable car operators must have learned their lesson by now”, I hear you rightly thinking. I hope however that in your company too, the management and technical department have understood the message. Bridging or deactivating a safety system is irresponsible and criminal. This also applies with failing to check whether such bad practices happen inconspicuously.
Have you ever experienced a Reliability and Maintenance Improvement Project where it feels like you are drowning? High level project plans, a lot of meetings and the latest buzzwords being thrown around to describe what you should do. Sound familiar?
Are Any of These Elements Holding Back Your Maintenance Improvement Strategy? A look at five common trouble areas that derail reliability
Over the last 15 plus years, I have watched many organizations both flounder and succeed at maintenance and reliability improvement. I have witnessed many spend considerable effort without creating the return on investment that they promised their stakeholders. In my opinion, there are 5 very common reasons that these experiences demonstrated success, or failure.