Condition Monitoring Systems Readdressed and Revised

Industry is turning from conventional condition monitoring systems to three areas of maintenance, namely safety, monitoring, and diagnosis.

Condition Monitoring Systems Readdressed and Revised

Big CMS players (companies like B&K, GE – including former Bently Nevada, SKF, Emerson, Allan-Bradley) have worked out a solid position on the maintenance market. However, the implementation of such brand name systems directs towards critical machinery and machinery, which calls for monitoring by regulations rather than solid industrial needs.

 

Jablonski_Adam_EC_Systems1

Adam Jablonski,

EC Systems,

ajablonski@ec-systems.pl ,

AGH University of Science and Technology

 

 

Due to a recent regress in the economy, potential private investments to CMS have decreased significantly, and industries are not interested as much in machine learning as they used to be. As a consequence, systems providing just monitoring functionality have become difficult to sell.

This scenario has readdressed, and currently redefined the expectations of condition monitoring systems. The currently accepted model changed direction from the typical monitoring activities to three explicit areas of maintenance, namely safety, monitoring, and diagnosis.

In this way, the literal notion of a classical CMS is no longer valid because it is too narrow. Moreover, a notion of SM&D (system of monitoring and diagnosis) is also too narrow. Therefore, a notion of safety-monitoring-and-diagnostic system seems more appropriate. The three aspects are discussed below.

Protection of Important Machines

Firstly, a currently demanded system is expected to be able to react real-time or quasi real-time upon detection of dangerous machine technical condition. Data collected and processes in a relatively high time resolution is processed, a number of predefined scalar analyses is calculated, and each of them is compared against allowable value, typical so-called alert threshold levels.

taulukko

Assessment of recent developments.

In case of threshold trespass, plus some possible hysteresis logic, an output (analogue or digital) is generated and sent directly to a relay, SCADA, or any other unit enabling the machine to immediate stop. In order to fulfil this requirement, the system must be characterized by high reliability, availability, and responsiveness. Because these features are typical for real-time operations, currently desired CMS are expected to be embedded on real-time operational systems platforms.

One of the aspects concerning protection, which still draw attention are recipes for setting threshold levels. Currently, three approaches are implemented. They are absolute values from norms, relative values from guidelines, and internal historical references.

In the first case, the most commonly applied norm are parts of a general ISO 10816 with a recently published group of ISO 13379 concerning data interpretation and diagnostic techniques. In the second case, guidelines provided by large CMS designers mention relative change of factors 2.5 and 10 as warning and raising an alarm respectively.

It is worth mentioning that it is still a large drawback of norms that they operate on wideband estimators, like root-mean-square of a velocity signal, which generally do not enable detection of fault development at an early stage. However, early fault detection is not crucial for protection of a machine.

Continuous Monitoring of Machine Health

Secondly, industrial clients expect improvements of the classical added value of CMS, which is monitoring of the machine health. In order to provide attractive monitoring, a system needs to provide an easy way to access and display all current and historical data on demand with a delay not exceeding a few seconds with a high degree of flexibility and display arrangement.

This expectation in turn imposes implementation of modern IT solutions, like instant and automated data transfer from an embedded unit to a local computer or to a database in case of a distributed system. It also includes the instant display of approximated large data sets, processing of very large raw data on demand, customized arrangement of things to display (like window undocking and moving to another screen) and user workspace definition, and finally user-friendly access to many features without displaying them all at a time, for instance with the use of ribbon technologies.

In opposition to protection, monitoring is expected to provide a clear upgrade from fault detection to identification. It should provide information that something is incorrect, and give details as what it is. In order to fulfil the latter requirement, a system needs to include a kinematic configuration of a machine with a phase marker. So it is a scheme that relates rotation of all the shafts to a reference rotation, on the basis of which characteristic component mechanical elements are automatically calculated.

Diagnostic Tools Are Needed

Tertiary, a modern CMS system needs to provide a variety of diagnostic tools. Typically those are charts and data extraction procedures for advanced data analysis. Such tools include in general verification of raw data against process channels, selection of raw data for referential analysis and display of historical data for fleet comparative analysis in case of distributed systems.

One particular demand that has been highly recognized by industrial clients is the access to all data that system records, and all data that the system calculates. It is no longer acceptable that CMS manufacturers provide only selected and moreover decimated data for customer, and require additional fees for further data access. With the usage of universal file formats, it is expected that a client is able to extract any data from the system, and process it with a customized application if needed.

Finally, regarding a general status of condition monitoring in recent years, certain aspects of development of condition monitoring and diagnostic systems have proven to be a success or a failure or at least have not reached expected level of maturity, which is summarized in table 1.

As illustrated in table 1, it turns out that industrial clients are not interested in fancy graphical solutions, because ultimately, after initially being amazed, a user becomes bored with too many pictographs. The wireless sensors still have footnotes about the final uncertainty of a range depending on a particular setup.

Large databases are currently not attractive because it is difficult to take high license costs without systems verification. And finally, the scientific achievements of analysis of root causes of failures are still customized sessions, and ready-to-use solutions are not available.
All of the above mentioned rough assessment given from industry might serve as a general guideline for CMS development or pivots for discussions serving towards the ultimate goal of an increase in safety, reliability, and maintenance costs.

Cmms | 20.11.2015

Latest articles

Neste, ReNew ELP and Licella to collaborate in utilization of waste plastic as a raw material

Neste, the world’s leading producer of renewable diesel, UK-based chemical recycling company ReNew ELP, and Australian technology developer Licella are joining forces in a development project to explore the potential of using mixed waste plastic as a raw material for fuels, chemicals, and new plastics. The companies are also collaborating with the aim to facilitate regulatory acceptance for chemical recycling. 

HSE | 16.8.2018

Bearing solution saves over 130,000 euros at energy plant

When a UK-based electricity producer was experiencing frequent breakdowns due to bearing failures in two industrial fan units, the plant requested the services of NSK to propose and implement a suitable solution. After performing an application review as part of NSK’s AIP (Added Value Programme), a change of bearing and fixing arrangement led to significant cost savings.

Asset Management | 16.8.2018

Wärtsilä Ballast Water Management Systems successfully tested for global compliance

Technology group Wärtsilä has announced that its Aquarius UV Ballast Water Management System (BWMS) has successfully completed all testing procedures required for United States Coastguard (USCG) type approval compliance. The documentation for full USCG type approval is being finalised for submission and awaits only final input from DNV-GL, the USCG approved independent laboratory.

Applications | 25.7.2018

Bilfinger relies on Comos software from Siemens for group‑wide digitalization

Siemens and industrial service provider Bilfinger SE have decided to step up their cooperative association, as Bilfinger drives forward digitalization using the Comos Engineering & Maintenance Platform across its many sites and subsidiaries spread around the globe. This software platform from the Siemens Digital Enterprise portfolio not only allows close cooperation between the different Bilfinger sites and its customers through the use of a shared database, but also offers sufficient flexibility to accommodate individual project requirements.

Cmms | 18.6.2018

How to Safely Align Wind Turbines

Safety engineers around the world can breathe easy. The PRUFTECHNIK ROTALIGN® and OPTALIGN® technology has made aligning machine shafts, especially gear shafts, much safer.

Partner Articles | 6.6.2018

Swedish Project Investigates Ways to Produce Fuel from Waste Tyres

The possibility of producing pyrolysis oil from worn out tyres is investigated in a research project run by RISE Research Institutes of Sweden together with Scandinavian Enviro Systems and Ragn-Sells with support from Vinnova.

R&D | 6.6.2018

Maintenance: A Necessary and Important Function in the Future

Euromaintenance 2016 will take place in Athens at the end of May. It is the ideal moment to reflect on maintenance in a European context. Euromaintenance is known as the summit for all involved in maintenance across Europe, it’s the place to be. The conference, with the support of the EFNMS, is the only commercially independent conference covering the topics we deal with in the maintenance world.

EFNMS | 20.5.2016