No Silver Bullets for Power Station Maintenance

Although today we have comprehensive methods for technical testing and sophisticated models for calculating and forecasting component behaviour, many of the defects identified in thermal power stations and process plants in recent years have been the result of inadequate servicing and maintenance. 

The problems in thermal power stations can be attributed to the fact that the ideal maintenance strategy is found only rarely, because stakeholders frequently focus on short-term cost reductions based on methodological approaches. When cost pressures increase, plant managers’ willingness to invest often decreases.

Operating costs may drop when modernisation measures and the acquisition of new equipment are postponed or fail to materialise at all; the operating risks, however, will increase. Stakeholders seeking to counteract this trend must choose the maintenance strategy best fitting the case at hand.

Failure recovery, preventative maintenance, condition-based maintenance, predictive maintenance, risk-based maintenance, reliability-centred maintenance or total productive maintenance – the strategies to choose from are virtually boundless.

However, ”maintenance” can never be equated with ”remediation” and ”repair”. And as the operating performance of every plant is unique, none of the possible approaches can be applied ”as is”, but must be adjusted to the case at hand.

A glance at the applicable standards and regulatory acts also fails to provide a solution. They are applied during manufacturing, before the plant is placed into service and in periodic inspections. But how can we succeed in achieving the right cost-benefit ratio when it comes to maintenance during operation?

Filtering out the Relevant Influencing Factors 

Deterministic approaches in maintenance focus mainly on causal ”if-then relations” based on detailed knowledge of the relevant components. While these approaches have proved their worth from the perspective of safety technology, they have repeatedly resulted in excessive maintenance measures because of the safety factors that must be observed in design.

Probabilistic approaches by contrast add probabilities to these ”if-then relations”. Risks are quantified by their frequency of occurrence and the severity of their consequences, thus enabling experts to prioritise actions and reduce costs. The downside includes uncertainties concerning the quality of the input data, and the high costs and efforts involved in complex events and fault-tree analyses.

A maintenance strategy tailored to the needs of a plant requires systematic knowledge of operations, plant condition and possible defects. Interconnected process equipment, machinery and electrical, instrumentation and control systems in particular are becoming the focus of particular interest.

Maintenance professionals should perform overall analysis to determine the key influencing variables and damage mechanisms. To do so, they combine deterministic and probabilistic tools, non-destructive testing, fracture mechanics and the finite element method. Some of the cracks and defects identified may not need to be repaired provided reliable assessment of their further propagation and behaviour can be made. 

Leadership skills are one of the key success factors in ensuring maintenance is used preventatively to maintain and optimise function. As this type of maintenance requires both ”creativity” and a solution-orientated approach, the engineers in charge must be able to motivate staff while at the same time assume responsibility for risks. They need to establish an organisation that is based on division of labour and characterised by outstanding clarity, consistency, employee appreciation and trust.

tuv

Hans Christian Schröder

TÜV SÜD Industrie Service GmbH,
www.tuev-sued.de/is

Asset Management | 19.5.2016

Latest articles

How ultrasonic sensors and artificial intelligence improve condition monitoring

In an industrial setting, assets are everything. A breakdown can cause hours  of downtime, and thus hours of lost productivity and lower financial gains. Preventative maintenance is one way facility managers counteract system entropy, but it is not perfect strategy. In some cases, a preventive approach to maintenance can actually lower the overall effectiveness of an asset. In the case of a valve for example, constant tightening can cause premature wear and tear.

Applications | 23.10.2018

To analyze or not to analyze, that is the question

Can we successfully improve reliability without analyzing reliability data?

Asset Management | 23.10.2018

Sustainability transformation: Are you ready for the change?

Companies which create truly sustainable businesses will remain competitive in the future.

HSE | 27.9.2018

Evaluating IT asset management software: Who do you trust?

Nowadays, more or less all companies have to deal with diverse kinds of IT assets. Using IT assets (software, hardware, digital media and networking) is no longer specific to the technology giants. 

Cmms | 7.9.2018

New methanol engine ready for the marine market

Within the frame of the GreenPilot project, Gothenburg-based ScandiNAOS AB has developed methanol engine concepts for the marine industry. A spark ignited methanol engine that wasn installed and tested in the Swedish Pilot boat “GreenPilot” has now been followed by a compression ignited methanol engine. The GreenPilot project is lead and initiated by Swedish Maritime Technology Forum, part of RISE Research Institutes of Sweden.

R&D | 4.9.2018

How to Safely Align Wind Turbines

Safety engineers around the world can breathe easy. The PRUFTECHNIK ROTALIGN® and OPTALIGN® technology has made aligning machine shafts, especially gear shafts, much safer.

Partner Articles | 6.6.2018

Maintenance: A Necessary and Important Function in the Future

Euromaintenance 2016 will take place in Athens at the end of May. It is the ideal moment to reflect on maintenance in a European context. Euromaintenance is known as the summit for all involved in maintenance across Europe, it’s the place to be. The conference, with the support of the EFNMS, is the only commercially independent conference covering the topics we deal with in the maintenance world.

EFNMS | 20.5.2016