Implementing a Successful Preventive Maintenance Program

CRISTAL UNION (CU) is an agroprocessing cooperative company ranking among the top European sugar and alcohol producers.
Most of its facilities are established in France (18 sites). The BOURDON site in AULNAT (in the Puy-de-Dôme département) has a production capacity of 4,500 tons of beets per day.

The company contacted SDT Ultrasound Solutions regarding the implementation of a preventive maintenance program based on the collection and analysis of ultrasonic signals. This project dealt with about 400 rotating machines.

Background

After purchasing an ultrasonic data collector and its analysis software tool, SDT and CU have defined the outline of a training program suited to the monitoring of rotating machines. The first step consisted in creating a database containing all 300 machines and then, performing the first data collection in order to determine the initial mechanical condition of each bearing. After simple on-site analysis (ultrasonic listening) and more detailed analysis (overall or static measurements and spectral or dynamic measurements), 1 800 thresholds were defined (pre-alarm, alarm and danger).

Using these background data, technicians were then able to identify, at a glance, the machines having an alarm condition.

Issue

This preventive maintenance program had three objectives:

- Assess a simple and quick data collection technique
- Control the reliability and relevance of ultrasonic measurements
- Calculate the return on investment

Untitled-8

 

Click Image to Enlarge
001

 

Click Image to Enlarge
002

Monitoring of a damaged motor bearing Machine: M779 Dirty beet conveyor line – Asynchronous electric motor

 

Using background data, technicians were able to identify, at a glance, the machines having an alarm condition.

Click Image to Enlarge
003

Measurement carried out on 11/12/2016

 

Click Image to Enlarge
004

Measurement carried out on 14/10/2017

Significant increase of +10 dBµV (RMS): the RMS value on the rear bearing of this motor increases from 7.7 dBµV to 17.3 dBµV.
According to SDT criteria, this increase corresponds to the early failure of the bearing.
Listening to the bearing and analysing the time spectra (see chart below) has allowed confirming this diagnosis by observing the emergence of significant peaks relative to this damage.

Obviously, the financial impact of a production shutdown right in the middle of the beet campaign is significant. It was then decided to closely monitor this bearing, so as to control the evolution of its condition. Monitoring helped schedule an operation on this machine at the end of the seasonal production, thus preventing a costly shutdown.

Click Image to Enlarge
005

Detection of a mechanical problem at the beginning of the campaign: Machine: M170 Gas pump CN16 – Asynchronous electrical motor (P=160 kW)

 

Click Image to Enlarge
Measurement carried out on 26/09/2017
Click Image to Enlarge
007

Measurement carried out on 03/12/2017

 

After a few weeks of production and the third measurement on this motor, the technician in charge of the ultrasonic measurement campaigns noticed that the bearing was extremely noisy. After comparison, the measured value showed a significant increase of the signal, which was confirmed by the time spectra (see below).

Click Image to Enlarge
008

 

After completion of the campaign and dismantling of the motor, the damage survey showed that the sealing ring of the front bearing was cracked. Despite the damaged sealing ring, injecting of a regular and appropriate quantity of grease prevented accelerated damage and untimely breaking of the bearing. 

Click Image to Enlarge
010

 

Click Image to Enlarge
011

Monitoring of a damaged motor bearing: Machine: TURBINE 1st JET M257 Forced ventilation – Asynchronous electric motor

 

Click Image to Enlarge
012

Measurement carried out on 25/09/2017

 

Click Image to Enlarge
013

Measurement carried out on 04/12/2017

After 3 months of monitoring of this electric motor, the RMS ultrasonic value of the rear bearing had significantly increased. The static measurements (overall levels) showed a significant increase of +12.9 dBµV, with the RMS value going from 26.9 dBµV (25/09/2017) to 39.8 dBµV (04/12/2017).

According to SDT criteria, this increase corresponds to an advanced failure of the bearing.

Listening to the bearing and analysing the time spectra (see chart below) have allowed confirming this diagnosis by observing the emergence of significant peaks relative to this bearing damage.
Based on the ultrasonic levels reached by both the rear and front motor bearings, the customer decided to replace this motor during a scheduled shutdown to avoid a sudden breaking and a detrimental production shutdown.

This forced ventilation system is designed to cool down a 160 kW motor that runs from 50 rpm up to 1,200 rpm and down again to 50 rpm in 3 minutes.

This damage originated from excessive unbalance due to the built-up of sugar dust on the blades of the forced ventilation fan.

Click Image to Enlarge
014

 

Click Image to Enlarge
015

Lubrication of a bearing Machine: WASHERY – M014 Beet screw – Asynchronous electric motor

 

CRISTAL UNION (CU) is an agroprocessing cooperative company ranking among the top European sugar and alcohol producers.

When performing the first measurement on this motor on 26/09/2017, the attention of the technician in charge of the  ultrasonic measurement campaign was drawn by the noise when listening to the front bearing of the motor.

He decided to grease it at once, which had an immediate effect: the original measurement of 33.9 dBµV dropped to 23.9 dBµV (see trend curves below).

Click Image to Enlarge
016

This bearing, which had been replaced between campaigns, was lacking grease.

The customer decided to implement regular monitoring of this electric motor and, on 21/10/2017, they observed a new increase of the ultrasonic measurements, from 23.9 dBµV (RMS) to 31.3 dBµV (RMS). After adding grease on that same day, the value dropped to 24.3 dBµV. The ultrasonic value remained stable until the end of the production campaign.

The customer was able to fully control the quantity and periodicity of greasing.

 

Conclusion

Mr. HERCEGFI, who is the Methods Manager and one of the instigators of the implementation of the ultrasonic methodology, told us why he favoured this technology over any other one: “Our goal was to implement a simple, fast and effective method to monitor a maximum number of machines. The ultrasonic data collector, along with its software tool, provided by SDT fully met our expectations. Reliable, simple and effective diagnoses could be issued. The onsite training was perfectly suited to our requirements and rapidly provided us with the autonomy we needed.”

Click Image to Enlarge
018

 

Key figures:

1.CU was able to avoid five to seven unscheduled shutdowns, which always occurred in the past.

2.CU used to systematically overhaul 80 to 100 electric motors each year. This year, overhaul will be performed on 27 machines only, i.e., a 60 percent decrease.

3.The in-depth monitoring allowed preventing sudden shutdowns, but also setting priorities for off-campaign maintenance operations.

4.The maintenance department was able to arrange for the provisioning of spare parts and/or the set-up of electric motors in stock, thus limiting the maintenance time.

5.CU was able to better schedule their greasing campaigns by observing a significant decrease of consumed quantities. For the 2018-2019 campaign, SDT and CU shall implement a bearing lubrication-specific ultrasonic program ensuring full traceability. It shall guarantee perfect greasing by indicating:
the proper grease,
the proper greasing location,
the proper greasing interval,
the proper quantity of grease to add,
the proper indicators for the lubrication condition.

6.Based on this first successful experience, CU is considering extending controls to other rotating machines (reduction gears, bearings, pumps, etc.), but also, taking advantage of the versatility of ultrasounds, to search for compressed air leaks and to control steam traps and electrical systems (corona, tracking, arcing).

Click Image to Enlarge
017

 

Patrice Dannepond

Asset Management | 24.10.2018

Latest articles

It’s About “Time”

At Bentley Systems, we have been talking to our users, especially owners, and it has become clear that despite our collective best efforts, there is a gap in the market.  Owners need easy access to real-time, accurate, engineering information and they need tools that make it simple to keep engineering data up-to-date, especially those engaged in brownfield and revamp projects.  It takes too much time and effort to gather and verify the information they need to make decisions effectively. And for older plants that do not have 3D models, there is simply no visual way to verify and check information easily.

Partner Articles | 10.12.2018

Energy savings 4.0

We have all read about it: leak detection should be a top priority since, if no leak detection program has been implemented, leaks can account for 30 to 40% of consumed volume. So, why is this issue still on the table? Why is it difficult to change things in the field?

Asset Management | 10.12.2018

How to Choose an Air Compressor, According to Science – 8 Factors to Consider

Buying an air compressor, for the first time, can be challenging in many ways. There is a lot going on behind this power tool that offers faster and more efficient performance. Before we get to know about the details of an air compressor then, let’s understand how it works. How do air compressors work?

Applications | 10.12.2018

Maintenance 4.0 hype or game changer?

Last September Antwerp (Belgium) hosted the Euromaintenance 4.0 conference. With 1187 participants from 64 different countries, the European maintenance federation EFNMS and the organisers BEMAS (Belgian Maintenance Association) and Reliabilityweb.com can look back on a very successful initiative. The massive interest and very positive vibe that prevailed confirm that maintenance 4.0 is currently at the centre of attention. But is this really justified? Isn't the whole buzz surrounding the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) just a hype that will have faded in a year's time?

Cmms | 10.12.2018

8 Ways to Identify and Eliminate Noise Hazards in the Workplace

Occupational noise hazards are one of the most common workplace safety concerns. Our hearing is sensitive and it does not take much to temporarily impair or permanently damage it. 

HSE | 10.12.2018

Bacterial Bandages, Natural Dyes and Recycled Fibres: Aalto Brings Materials Revolution to Slush

New materials play an important role in sustainable development and combatting climate change. New uses for old materials can also be a major industrial opportunity: for example, the value of biomass from forests in Finland can be doubled if used for manufacturing products of higher added value.

R&D | 4.12.2018

Maintenance: A Necessary and Important Function in the Future

Euromaintenance 2016 will take place in Athens at the end of May. It is the ideal moment to reflect on maintenance in a European context. Euromaintenance is known as the summit for all involved in maintenance across Europe, it’s the place to be. The conference, with the support of the EFNMS, is the only commercially independent conference covering the topics we deal with in the maintenance world.

EFNMS | 20.5.2016